what is it like to take another persons life

"Nobody has the correct to have another man'southward life"

For many years, I have been skeptic of people so full of heart who grandly emphasized on abolishing capital punishment. And at that place was reason enough behind thinking it; justice has been established through claret in the by. Imagine if one of your relatives or shut friend was murdered by a psychopath - wouldn't your wrath and sense of justice boil every bit to want this psycho's life taken away as well ? How can y'all stand seeing that human garbage to walk the earth and breathe and alive ? However, my belief in this controversy has been put to a examination recently. No claret needs to exist spilt in the globe, if only we all accept censor plenty. War is idiocy itself, with plenty reason. Equally I was having a walk with my girlfriend, we began to talk nigh the result of death sentence. I believed that information technology was needed, for the reasons given in a higher place, and I explained this to her. However, she did not seem to think and then, and I failed to convince her. And it is now that I am more than inclined to stand up against death penalty. Nobody has the correct to take another human being'southward life. Somehow, humans made laws and dared to make up one's mind who lived and died - man is playing God. Simply God has the right to make up one's mind who should live or die. A psychopath who has killed innocent people must be locked away and imprisonned for life. This is for the condom of others, and God will approximate him from thence. We must not think our tax money is spent in an ill-advised style past being spent on feeding and keeping the psychopaths live. We are paying tax money to comprise them and keep them from harming anyone else. This would exist included in "social security". All that human being can, must, and has the right to do is take the conscience to stop bloodshed by capturing and containing murderers and people with murderous intent. Judgement is not ours to do, no matter how biting we feel. In the finish, has anyone really felt satisfaction and been relieved from grief through death punishment ? Wrath and Vengeance creates only devastation ..... Anyone daring to challenge my view on this controversial, simply about of import issue ?

This is perfect!... For a christian. Not anybody believes in your imaginary friend. Edit: I myself am a christian and I am against the death penalty. Thought I should mail service this before someone got the wrong thought.

Depends... Really a Psychopath has a unlike mentality and achieves fulfillment through other ways. It's obvious that they deserve to be jailed. I believe that we do have the right take the life away from others depending on the choices that they themselves have made, I'll elaborate afterwards...

Hell, don't jails make a profit by using inmates for cheap labor?

Osaka 26380 Posts A death sentence statement backed by religious conviction. This is going to go well. Your terminal sentence is pretty provocative too. "In the end, has anyone really felt satisfaction and been relieved from grief through death penalty?" Many people who accept gone through the process say yes.

Nobody has the right to take another human being's life. [...] man is playing God. Only God has the right to determine who should live or die. Your argument hinges largely on a belief in God (and moreover, the aforementioned God). Since many people don't believe or believe in a dissimilar God/Gods, this isn't sufficient to brand any declaration that "because only God has that right, killing is wrong."

I really can merely speak from a western N American perspective on the effect. But the death penalty poses serious bug. Start of all cases get overturned. It's very easy to discover cases where people who were establish guilty of murder and sentenced to death were afterward establish innocent. http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/09/07/090907fa_fact_grann?yrail is a reeeeally long simply fantastic article about such a case. Death is a permanent penalty and no review volition always be possible. Second, personally I feel that the death sentence is cruel and unusual punishment. The correct to life is an unalienable right. I know in the Usa that often information technology is cheaper to ship someone to prison for life rather than execute them due to legal procedures. Yous cite god equally an your reasoning, which is fine. But in countries that take seperated church and land at that place must exist secular reasoning for or against the penalty. Luckily there is.

On March 02 2011 15:42 Manifesto7 wrote: A capital punishment argument backed past religious confidence. This is going to become well. Your last sentence is pretty provocative too. "In the finish, has anyone really felt satisfaction and been relieved from grief through decease penalty?" Many people who accept gone through the procedure say yep. I feel like this thread should be locked for the reasons y'all posted. I can't tell if the OP is baiting or not with his religious bias. Regardless, a topic like this should either be in blogs because it is relating a personal experience or it should take an OP founded on logic, not faith

Ugh, why are you lot using religion as your basis. I'thousand not religious. There is no "playing God," and I detest that phrase in itself. Can't believe yous even had the brazenness to state that y'all think people don't find closure through the death penalty, your notions are ridiculous and naiively based upon the assumption we are even religious in the first place.

The ONLY thing that makes me against the death penalty is the fact that our judicial branch isnt perfect, we can and have in the past, executed innocent people. If it wasnt for the margin of mistake, i would exist for information technology a thousand times over.. You dont take my family from this earth and deserve to live some other day.. Y'all tin can sit here and say, what gives you the right to decide that? Well what gave him the right to take life? Religion definitely isnt the mutual denominator.. in this debate.. Nosotros should take it off the table completely imo.

I've always been of the conventionalities that laws are meant to deter crime, not punish criminals. What good volition killing a criminal practice? Life in prison is enough to prevent him from doing whatsoever more harm. A living human is infinitely more useful than a expressionless human. Fifty-fifty a criminal can live a productive life in jail.

If the psychopath is gonna be imprisoned for life, it will be in the name of justice, NOT because he is harmful to others. People who have sick mentality to harm other people'south life are sent to mental hospitals. I think this i of those "no right reply" questions. Some people feel it is unfair for the murderer to alive on while his victim does not even live.

NOTE: I also disagree the that the right to alive is some inalienable right. Y'all very well may forfeit your right to life depending on the actions you make. And yes, it's for society to guess, tough shit if you lot exercise the incorrect shit in the incorrect area.

The problem with the capital punishment is that it inculcates the idea that killing is endorsed by the state and therefore individuals tend to subconsiously be more inclined to murder. It is no coincidence that u.s.a. with the highest criminal offence and murder rates are those that nonetheless practice death sentence. While states that have abolished the death penalization have seen substantial drops in violent and nonviolent law-breaking.

On March 02 2011 xv:37 spkim1 wrote: Nobody has the right to take another man's life. Somehow, humans made laws and dared to decide who lived and died - man is playing God. Just God has the right to decide who should live or die I don't believe that god exists therefore he can't have any such right. If anyone does, it'southward humanity/society. A psychopath who has killed innocent people must be locked away and imprisonned for life. This is for the safety of others, and God will estimate him from thence. We must not retrieve our revenue enhancement coin is spent in an sick-brash manner past existence spent on feeding and keeping the psychopaths live. We are paying tax money to comprise them and keep them from harming anyone else. This would be included in "social security". Personally I'm in favour of the death penalty for murder, why waste all that money for decades on keeping this person live when you could merely solve the problem on twenty-four hours one with a bullet to the head. All that human can, must, and has the right to exercise is accept the conscience to stop bloodshed by capturing and containing murderers and people with murderous intent. Judgement is non ours to do, no matter how biting we experience. This sounds like some kind of minority report blazon thing, if people commit crimes then they forfeit their rights and the police can deal with them as it sees fit. In the terminate, has anyone really felt satisfaction and been relieved from grief through death sentence ? Wrath and Vengeance creates but destruction ..... I'thousand sure many people throughout history take had plenty satisfaction from avenging the death of a friend/relative etc. and it punishes the political party responsible for murder in the get-go identify.

Play God? So when an ape kills another male ape for coming into his territory, that ape is playing God? Oh wait I forgot. You guys don't care about brute behavior.

I am not certain what exactly your views are? I agree with you on the result of death penalty. All the same, y'all say that you are against expiry penalisation because it's just God'due south right to accept away another'due south life? Then I disagree with yous as I don't believe in God and I find information technology hard to believe that there is an afterlife. If someone killed me, then I don't care about getting revenge because I am already expressionless. I don't know if I would get satisfaction or relieved from grieve through the expiry penalization, as I never was in this circumstance. I don't imagine I would exist, just and so again I don't know. I imagine it would bring temporary relief like releasing anger. Simply if the victim wanted revenge and I cared about the victim, then I would whole heartily be willing to see the vengeful human action carried out. I am besides intrigued to someone who may have personally experienced this and what their view on death punishment is... Edit: during the time I wrote this response, there have been several replies. I am delighted that I am not the merely atheist in the fox hole. =p

Fenrax United States 5018 Posts Recently a homo in Germany killed and abused a ten year one-time. He did it because he liked to have control over someone. His victim was picked randomly. He claimed his boss was being mean to him on the cell phone prior to the incident, non that that would be an excuse, simply he likewise lied in that location. I would accept no trouble if a courtroom decided to get him executed.

A life is a silly matter to waste, and i similar your signature because really i used to fear death but non any more. its the most certain matter to ever happen and when u alive by fearing death how can u truly live. but for the death penalty i call back it should be aloud but considering that life is now wasted and since he used his life to ruin someone elses or more than than just i person i think we have the right to choose to let him live or not. if anything god gave usa the right to cull to let people live or dice. god gave him life and if they dont intendance how they utilize and just cause harm then i think its improve for the residuum humanity to have that ane person die. but it is a very hard affair to argue this side especially if u follow the ten commandments... im drunk so go ahead and flame me. brand my day

wait wait expect... let me try and solve this using my uncomplicated noesis of the christian faith. God made everything. God makes criminals, God makes victims, and God makes the people that flip the switch on the electrical chair. ?????????????????????????????????????????????????? "Anyone daring to challenge my view on this controversial, but most important issue ?"

dyethrioned1972.blogspot.com

Source: https://tl.net/forum/closed-threads/197708-nobody-has-the-right-to-take-another-mans-life

Share this post